One scenario, three rules sets

[Norm]

Thank you, I love these rule comparison type posts.

[Duke Speedy of Leighton]

Very good report

[paulr]

Interesting :-
Looking forward to game three

[Chris Pringle]

Very interesting exercise, thanks, Andy.

Why stop at three rulesets?   

Chris

Bloody Big BATTLES!
https://uk.groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/BBB_wargames/info
http://bloodybigbattles.blogspot.com/

[Leman]

Problem is, Chris, the scenario is a very small one featuring two avant grades clashing, so it is at the battalion level. However, it could be rejigged as a BBB and would probably work well with my 2mm Hanoverian and Prussian armies, maybe translating as a much larger attempt for the Hanoverians trying to push south across the river to link with German 8th Corps. The bridging point would still be vital as being the only crossing for artillery and supply wagons. I will suggest this to my gaming buddy to see if he would like to try this as an extra fourth game. The chateau could become a town and the inn a riverside village.

[Lord Kermit of Birkenhead]

So two cultural snobs are fighting ?

[Leman]

Oh Ian. Are you the person responsible for upsetting Frank Field?

[Lord Kermit of Birkenhead]

Have met him a few times, and rung him, but no I didnt vote BNP......I did vote for him.

[Chris Pringle]

it could be rejigged as a BBB and would probably work well with my 2mm Hanoverian and Prussian armies, maybe translating as a much larger attempt for the Hanoverians trying to push south across the river to link with German 8th Corps. The bridging point would still be vital as being the only crossing for artillery and supply wagons. I will suggest this to my gaming buddy to see if he would like to try this as an extra fourth game.

It do seem an obvious thing to do. I hope your oppo goes for it, as it could make for a really interesting comparison.

Chris